Choosing the right toilet for your bathroom can be more complicated than it seems. When deciding between a round toilet and an elongated toilet, several factors come into play, such as comfort, space, style, and budget. This comprehensive guide will help you understand the differences between Round toilet vs elongated, their pros and cons, and how to decide which one is best for your home.
The Basics: What Are Round and Elongated Toilets?
Round toilet vs elongated
Round Toilets
Shape: A round toilet bowl has a circular shape and is generally more compact.
Size: Round toilets typically measure about 16.5 inches from the bolts to the front. This makes them an ideal choice for smaller bathrooms and limited spaces.
Elongated Toilets
Shape: An elongated toilet bowl has an oval shape, extending a bit more forward.
Size: Elongated toilets usually measure about 18.5 inches from the bolts to the front. They occupy more space but offer additional comfort.
Pros and Cons of Round Toilets
Round toilets come with their advantages and disadvantages. Let’s explore them:
Pros
Space-Saving
Compact Design: Round toilets are more compact, making them perfect for bathrooms where space is at a premium. They fit well in smaller areas and offer more room for other fixtures.
Cost-Effective
Lower Cost: Round toilets are generally less expensive than elongated models. If you’re on a budget, a round toilet can save you money without sacrificing function.
Child-Friendly
Smaller Size: The smaller bowl size can be more comfortable for children. They might find it easier to use compared to elongated toilets, which can be too large for them.
Cons
Comfort Levels
Less Comfortable: The smaller, circular design may not offer as much seating comfort as elongated toilets. Adults, especially taller individuals, might find them less comfortable for extended use.
Style Limitations
Aesthetic: Round toilets may not have the same sleek and modern look as elongated models. If style and aesthetics are crucial for your bathroom design, this might be a drawback.
Pros and Cons of Elongated Toilets
Elongated toilets also have their set of benefits and drawbacks:
Pros
Enhanced Comfort
Increased Comfort: The elongated shape provides more seating area. This can be more comfortable for adults, offering support and ease of use, especially during longer periods.
Modern Design
Aesthetics: Elongated toilets often have a more modern, sleek look. They can enhance the overall appearance of a contemporary bathroom design.
Functionality
Better Flushing: The design of elongated toilets can allow for a more efficient flushing mechanism, which can contribute to better hygiene and cleanliness.
Cons
Space Requirements
Larger Footprint: The elongated design needs more space. This can be a problem in smaller bathrooms, reducing available room for other fixtures and movement.
Higher Costs
Increased Expense: Elongated toilets tend to be more expensive compared to round models. This can impact your budget, especially if you’re planning an extensive bathroom renovation.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Round toilet vs elongated
When deciding between a round and elongated toilet, consider the following factors:
Bathroom Space
Measurement: Measure your bathroom space accurately. Ensure that your chosen toilet fits comfortably without making the area feel cramped.
User Comfort
Daily Use: Think about who will be using the toilet most often. If adults or taller individuals primarily use the bathroom, an elongated toilet might provide better comfort.
Budget Constraints
Cost vs. Feature: Balance your budget with the features you prioritize. If you need to save money, a round toilet might be the best choice, but consider if the slight increase in cost for an elongated model could provide better long-term satisfaction.
Bathroom Style
Design Cohesion: Consider the overall style of your bathroom. An elongated toilet could fit better with modern, sleek designs, while a round toilet might suit a more traditional or compact bathroom layout.
Family Needs
Children’s Comfort: If children will be using the toilet frequently, the round design might be more comfortable and easier for them to use.
Installation Considerations
Ease of Installation
Compatibility: Most toilets are designed to fit standard plumbing setups. However, ensure that the model you choose is compatible with your existing plumbing to avoid additional installation costs.
Professional Assistance
Hire a Plumber: While installing a toilet can be a DIY project, hiring a professional plumber can ensure the job is done correctly, especially in cases where space or existing plumbing might pose challenges.
Maintenance and Durability
Cleaning
Surface Area: Elongated toilets might be slightly easier to clean due to their straight lines and larger surface area. However, the difference is marginal and both types can be maintained with regular cleaning.
Durability
Quality of Materials: The durability of a toilet depends more on the quality of materials used rather than its shape. Invest in a well-made model to ensure longevity and reliability.
Some current toilet trends that are growing in popularity:
Smart Toilets:
Integrated Bidet Functions: Smart toilets with built-in bidet features, including adjustable water pressure, temperature control, and oscillating spray patterns.
Heated Seats: Toilets with heated seats for added comfort, especially during colder months.
Automatic Lid and Flush: Sensors that automatically open/close the lid and flush the toilet, enhancing convenience and hygiene.
Deodorizing Systems: Inbuilt systems that neutralize odors using activated carbon or other technologies.
Night Lights: Soft, ambient lighting for better visibility at night without the need for bright bathroom lights.
Remote Control and App Connectivity: Toilets controlled via remote or mobile apps for personalized settings and ease of use.
Water Efficiency:
Dual-Flush Toilets: Options for reduced water usage per flush, usually featuring two buttons or handles for different flush volumes.
Low-Flow Toilets: Designed to use significantly less water per flush, meeting or exceeding water efficiency standards.
Water-Saving Technologies: Advanced flushing systems that optimize water usage without sacrificing performance.
Design and Aesthetics:
Wall-Mounted Toilets: Create a sleek, modern look while making cleaning underneath the toilet easier.Compact and Space-Saving Designs: Ideal for small bathrooms, these toilets maximize space without sacrificing functionality.
One-Piece Toilets: Offer a streamlined appearance and are easier to clean compared to two-piece toilets.
Variety of Finishes: Beyond the classic white porcelain, finishes in matte black, stainless steel, or custom colors to match interior design.
Minimalist Designs: Clean lines and simple shapes that complement contemporary bathroom styles.
Accessibility and Comfort:
Comfort Height Toilets: Higher seat height for easier sitting and standing, beneficial for elderly users or those with mobility issues.
Elongated Bowls: Provide more comfort than round bowls due to the extra space.
ADA-Compliant Toilets: Designed to meet the standards of the Americans with Disabilities Act, ensuring accessibility for all users.
Hygiene and Health Features:
Antimicrobial Surfaces: Toilets with surfaces treated to resist bacteria, mold, and mildew.
Self-Cleaning Toilets: Features like UV lights or electrolyzed water systems that clean the bowl after each use.
Air Purification: Inbuilt air purifiers to reduce unpleasant odors and improve bathroom air quality.
Sustainability:
Recycled Materials: Toilets made from or incorporating recycled materials for a more eco-friendly option.
Composting Toilets: Increasingly popular for off-grid living or sustainable housing, these toilets compost waste without the need for water or sewer connections.
These trends reflect the growing demand for toilets that offer advanced features, improved hygiene, water efficiency, and stylish designs to enhance the overall bathroom experience.
Conclusion
Round toilet vs elongated
Choosing between a round and elongated toilet involves evaluating several factors, including space, user comfort, budget, and bathroom style. Each type has its advantages and drawbacks, so consider your specific needs and preferences before making a decision.
Round toilets are compact, cost-effective, and child-friendly, making them suitable for smaller bathrooms and tighter budgets. On the other hand, elongated toilets offer enhanced comfort, modern aesthetics, and better functionality, making them a preferred choice for those seeking luxury and style.
By carefully evaluating your options and considering the factors outlined in this guide, you can make an informed decision that meets your needs and enhances the comfort and functionality of your bathroom. Happy shopping!
